DNA-based assay for calorimetric determination of protein concentrations in pure or mixed solutions.

It was recently reported that values of the transition heat capacities, as measured by differential scanning calorimetry, for two globular proteins and a short DNA hairpin in NaCl buffer are essentially equivalent, at equal concentrations (mg/mL). To validate the broad applicability of this phenomenon, additional evidence for this equivalence is presented that reveals it does not depend on DNA sequence, buffer salt, or transition temperature (Tm). Based on the equivalence of transition heat capacities, a calorimetric method was devised to determine protein concentrations in pure and complex solutions. The scheme uses direct comparisons between the thermodynamic stability of a short DNA hairpin standard of known concentration, and thermodynamic stability of protein solutions of unknown concentrations. Sequences of two DNA hairpins were designed to confer a near 20°C difference in their Tm values. In all cases, evaluated protein concentrations determined from the DNA standard curves agreed with the UV-Vis concentration for monomeric proteins. For multimeric proteins evaluated concentrations were greater than determined by UV-Vis suggesting the calorimetric approach can also be an indicator of molecular stoichiometry.

Calorimetric analysis using DNA thermal stability to determine protein concentration.

It was recently reported for two globular proteins and a short DNA hairpin in NaCl buffer that values of the transition heat capacities, Cp,DNA and Cp,PRO, for equal concentrations (mg/mL) of DNA and proteins, are essentially equivalent (differ by less than 1%). Additional evidence for this equivalence is presented that reveals this phenomenon does not depend on DNA sequence, buffer salt, or Tm. Sequences of two DNA hairpins were designed to confer a near 20°C difference in their Tm's. For the molecules, in NaCl and CsCl buffer the evaluated Cp,PRO and Cp,DNA were equivalent. Based on the equivalence of transition heat capacities, a calorimetric method was devised to determine protein concentrations in pure and complex solutions. The scheme uses direct comparisons between the thermodynamic stability of a short DNA hairpin standard of known concentration, and thermodynamic stability of protein solutions of unknown concentrations. In all cases, evaluated protein concentrations determined from the DNA standard curve agreed with the UV-Vis concentration for monomeric proteins. For samples of multimeric proteins, streptavidin (tetramer), Herpes Simplex Virus glycoprotein D (trimer/dimer), and a 16 base pair DNA duplex (dimer), evaluated concentrations were greater than determined by UV-Vis by factors of 3.94, 2.65, and 2.15, respectively.

Equivalence of the transition heat capacities of proteins and DNA.

It has been reported for many globular proteins that the native heat capacity at 25 °C, per gram, is the same. This has been interpreted to indicate that heat capacity is a fundamental property of native proteins that provides important information on molecular structure and stability. Heat capacities for both proteins and DNA has been suggested to be related to universal effects of hydration/solvation on native structures. Here we report on results from thermal denaturation analysis of two well-known proteins, human serum albumin and lysozyme, and a short DNA hairpin. The transition heat capacities at the Tm for the three molecules were quantitatively evaluated by differential scanning calorimetry. When normalized per gram rather than per mol the transition heat capacities were found to be precisely equivalent. This observation for the transition heat capacities of the proteins is consistent with previous reports. However, an identical transition heat capacity for DNA has not been reported and was unexpected. Further analysis of the collected data suggested a mass dependence of hydration effects on thermal denaturation that is preserved at the individual protein amino acid and DNA base levels. Equivalence of transition heat capacities suggests the possibility of a universal role of hydration effects on the thermal stability of both proteins and DNA.

Ligand binding constants for human serum albumin evaluated by ratiometric analysis of DSC thermograms.

This paper describes an expanded application of our recently reported method (Eskew et al., Analytical Biochemistry 621,1 2021) utilizing thermogram signals for thermal denaturation measured by differential scanning calorimetry. Characteristic signals were used to quantitatively evaluate ligand binding constants for human serum albumin. In our approach the ensemble of temperature dependent calorimetric responses for various protein-ligand mixtures and native HSA were compared, in a ratiometric manner, to extract binding constants and stoichiometries. Protein/ligand mixtures were prepared at various ligand concentrations and subjected to thermal denaturation analysis by calorimetry. Measurements provided the melting temperature, Tm, and free-energy ΔGcal(37°C) for melting ligand-bound Albumin as a function of ligand concentration. Concentration dependent behaviors of these parameters derived from protein/ligand mixtures were used to construct dose-response curves. Fitting of dose-response curves yielded quantitative evaluation of the ligand binding constant and semi-quantitative estimates of the binding stoichiometry. Many of the ligands had known binding affinity for Albumin with binding constants reported in the literature. Evaluated binding parameters for the ligands impressively agreed with reported literature values determined using other standard experimental methods. Results are reported for 29 drug ligands binding to Albumin. These validate our calorimetry-based process for applications in pre-clinical drug screening.

Ligand binding to natural and modified human serum albumin.

This paper reports evaluation of ligand binding constants for unmodified or biotinylated HSA (HSAB) for two well-known HSA binding ligands, naproxen and bromocresol green. Results demonstrate differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) is a reliable quantitative method for straight-forward and rapid evaluation of ligand binding constants for HSA and modified derivatives. DSC measured the thermodynamic stability of free and ligand-bound HSA and HSAB at pH = 6.0, 7.4 and 8.0. DSC analysis provided a quantitative gauge of responses of HSA and HSAB thermodynamic stability to ligand binding. The influence of different levels of biotinylation of HSAB on ligand binding, and how ligand binding varied as a function of pH for these molecules was also examined. In the three pH environments, biotinylation increased stability of HSAB alone compared to free HSA at pH 7.4. Stabilities of free protein and ligand-bound complexes varied with pH in the order, pH = 6.0>7.4>8.0. Our analytical approach provided very accurate estimates for known binding constants of these ligands for HSA. Results revealed, for both ligands, extent of biotinylation of HSAB affected binding, reducing binding constants from three to 100-fold. DSC analysis was able to delineate inter-relationships between molecular structure and thermodynamic stability of HSA and HSAB bound by ligands; and their variations with pH.

The paradox of multiplex DNA melting on a surface.

Under equilibrium conditions, there are two regimes of target capture on a surface--target limited and probe limited. In the probe limited regime, the melting curve from multiplex target dissociation from the surface exhibits a single transition due to a reverse displacement mechanism of the low affinity species. The melting curve cannot be used in analytical methods to resolve heteroduplexes; only with the simplex system can proper thermodynamics be obtained.

Statistical analysis of plasma thermograms measured by differential scanning calorimetry.

Melting curves of human plasma measured by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), known as thermograms, have the potential to markedly impact diagnosis of human diseases. A general statistical methodology is developed to analyze and classify DSC thermograms to analyze and classify thermograms. Analysis of an acquired thermogram involves comparison with a database of empirical reference thermograms from clinically characterized diseases. Two parameters, a distance metric, P, and correlation coefficient, r, are combined to produce a 'similarity metric,' ρ, which can be used to classify unknown thermograms into pre-characterized categories. Simulated thermograms known to lie within or fall outside of the 90% quantile range around a median reference are also analyzed. Results verify the utility of the methods and establish the apparent dynamic range of the metric ρ. Methods are then applied to data obtained from a collection of plasma samples from patients clinically diagnosed with SLE (lupus). High correspondence is found between curve shapes and values of the metric ρ. In a final application, an elementary classification rule is implemented to successfully analyze and classify unlabeled thermograms. These methods constitute a set of powerful yet easy to implement tools for quantitative classification, analysis and interpretation of DSC plasma melting curves.

Origins of the "nucleation" free energy in the hybridization thermodynamics of short duplex DNA.

Thermodynamic parameters deltaH(cal), deltaS(cal), and deltaG(cal) of the melting transitions for 19 short DNA/DNA duplexes ranging in length from 6 to 35 base pairs were systematically evaluated by differential scanning calorimetry melting experiments carried out at four salt concentrations from 85 mM to 1.0 M [Na+]. As expected, thermodynamic stabilities of the DNA duplexes increased with length and increasing [Na+]. From plots of deltaG25 versus duplex length, extrapolation to N = 0 provided estimates on values of deltaG(cal)25 (N = 0) as a function of [Na+], corresponding to the free-energy of the "hypothetical duplex" having zero base pairs, but occupying precisely the same molar volume as the fully base paired duplex. The values obtained for deltaG(cal)25 (N = 0) were 3.68, 5.59, 7.86, and 8.68 kcal/mol in 1.00, 0.60, 0.30, and 0.085 M Na+, respectively. These values are in reasonable agreement with published values of the nucleation or initiation free-energy, attributed to formation of the first base pair in a short duplex compared to formation of the remaining base pairs. A statistical thermodynamic formulation of the association of two strands accounting for displaced solvent was utilized to relate [Na+]-dependent deltaG(cal)25 (N = 0) values to configuration integrals for both single and duplex strands. Relative differences between two single strands in their standard states and the duplex (in its standard state), and solvent displaced during the annealing process was taken into account. This analysis provides a new vantage point to view what has historically been referred to as the helix initiation or nucleation parameter and provides an alternate interpretation and mechanism for the nucleation complex in duplex formation.

Conformational equilibria of bulged sites in duplex DNA studied by EPR spectroscopy.

Conformational flexibility in nucleic acids provides a basis for complex structures, binding, and signaling. One-base bulges directly neighboring single-base mismatches in nucleic acids can be present in a minimum of two distinct conformations, complicating the examination of the thermodynamics by calorimetry or UV-monitored melting techniques. To provide additional information about such structures, we demonstrate how electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) active spin-labeled base analogues, base-specifically incorporated into the DNA, are monitors of the superposition of different bulge-mismatch conformations. EPR spectra provide information about the dynamic environments of the probe. This information is cast in terms of "dynamic signatures" that have an underlying basis in structural variations. By examining the changes in the equilibrium of the different states across a range of temperatures, the enthalpy and entropy of the interconversion among possible conformations can be determined. The DNA constructs with a single bulge neighboring a single-base mismatch ("bulge-mismatches") may be approximately modeled as an equilibrium between two possible conformations. This structural information provides insight into the local composition of the bulge-mismatch sequences. Experiments on the bulge-mismatches show that basepairing across the helix can be understood in terms of purine and pyrimidine interactions, rather than specific bases. Measurements of the enthalpy and entropy of formation for the bulge-mismatches by differential scanning calorimetry and UV-monitored melting confirm that the formation of bulge-mismatches is in fact more complicated than a simple two-state process, consistent with the base-specific spectral data that bulge-mismatches exist in multiple conformations in the premelting temperature region. We find that the calculations with the nearest-neighbor (NN) model for the two likely conformations do not correlate well with the populations of structures and thermodynamic parameters inferred from the base-specific EPR dynamics probe. We report that the base-specific spin probes are able to identify a bistable, temperature dependent, switching between conformations for a particular complex bulged construct.

Influence of buffer species on the thermodynamics of short DNA duplex melting: sodium phosphate versus sodium cacodylate.

Thermodynamic parameters of the melting transitions of 53 short duplex DNAs were experimentally evaluated by differential scanning calorimetry melting curve analysis. Solvents for the DNA solutions contained approximately 1 M Na+ and either 10 mM cacodylate or phosphate buffer. Thermodynamic parameters obtained in the two solvent environments were compared and quantitatively assessed. Thermodynamic stabilities (deltaG(o) (25 degrees C)) of the duplexes studied ranged from quite stable perfect match duplexes (approximately -30 kcal/mol) to relatively unstable mismatch duplexes (approximately -9 kcal/mol) and ranged in length from 18 to 22 basepairs. A significant difference in stability (average free energy difference of approximately 3 kcal/mol) was found for all duplexes melted in phosphate (greater stability) versus cacodylate buffers. Measured effects of buffer species appear to be relatively unaffected by duplex length or sequence content. The popular sets of published nearest-neighbor (n-n) stability parameters for Watson-Crick (w/c) and single-base mismatches were evaluated from melting studies performed in cacodylate buffer (SantaLucia and Hicks, Annu. Rev. Biophys. Biomol. Struct. 2004, 33, 415). Thus, when using these parameters to make predictions of sequence dependent stability of DNA oligomers in buffers other than cacodylate (e.g., phosphate) one should be mindful that in addition to sodium ion concentration, the type of buffer species also provides a minor but significant contribution to duplex stability. Such considerations could potentially influence results of sequence dependent analysis using published n-n parameters and impact results of thermodynamic calculations. Such calculations and analyses are typically employed in the design and interpretation of DNA multiplex hybridization experiments.

Cellulose/DNA hybrid nanomaterials.

Cellulose nanocrystals (CNXLs) have drawn attention from researchers for their remarkable reinforcing abilities and excellent mechanical properties. CNXLs typically have high aspect ratios of around 20-50 (length/width), low density of around 1.6 g/cc, high stiffness (135 to 155 GPa), and strength (estimated at 7500 MPa). Here we utilize CNXLs in a bottom-up hierarchical assembly to produce a macroscale material. Single-stranded oligonucleotides with an amino modifier were successfully grafted on CNXLs. The molecular recognition ability of the oligomeric base pairs was then utilized by duplexing complementary oligonucleotides grafted onto separate CNXL populations. The resulting hybrid nanomaterials were analyzed using dynamic light scattering, atomic force microscopy, and UV spectroscopy.

Electrical detection of the temperature induced melting transition of a DNA hairpin covalently attached to gold interdigitated microelectrodes.

The temperature induced melting transition of a self-complementary DNA strand covalently attached at the 5' end to the surface of a gold interdigitated microelectrode (GIME) was monitored in a novel, label-free, manner. The structural state of the hairpin was assessed by measuring four different electronic properties of the GIME (capacitance, impedance, dissipation factor and phase angle) as a function of temperature from 25 degrees C to 80 degrees C. Consistent changes in all four electronic properties of the GIME were observed over this temperature range, and attributed to the transition of the attached single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) from an intramolecular, folded hairpin structure to a melted ssDNA. The melting curve of the self-complementary single strand was also measured in solution using differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) and UV absorbance spectroscopy. Temperature dependent electronic measurements on the surface and absorbance versus temperature values measured in solution experiments were analyzed assuming a two-state process. The model analysis provided estimates of the thermodynamic transition parameters of the hairpin on the surface. Two-state analyses of optical melting data and DSC measurements provided evaluations of the thermodynamic transition parameters of the hairpin in solution. Comparison of surface and solution measurements provided quantitative evaluation of the effect of the surface on the thermodynamics of the melting transition of the DNA hairpin.

DNA multiplex hybridization on microarrays and thermodynamic stability in solution: a direct comparison.

Hybridization intensities of 30 distinct short duplex DNAs measured on spotted microarrays, were directly compared with thermodynamic stabilities measured in solution. DNA sequences were designed to promote formation of perfect match, or hybrid duplexes containing tandem mismatches. Thermodynamic parameters DeltaH degrees , DeltaS degrees and DeltaG degrees of melting transitions in solution were evaluated directly using differential scanning calorimetry. Quantitative comparison with results from 63 multiplex microarray hybridization experiments provided a linear relationship for perfect match and most mismatch duplexes. Examination of outliers suggests that both duplex length and relative position of tandem mismatches could be important factors contributing to observed deviations from linearity. A detailed comparison of measured thermodynamic parameters with those calculated using the nearest-neighbor model was performed. Analysis revealed the nearest-neighbor model generally predicts mismatch duplexes to be less stable than experimentally observed. Results also show the relative stability of a tandem mismatch is highly dependent on the identity of the flanking Watson-Crick (w/c) base pairs. Thus, specifying the stability contribution of a tandem mismatch requires consideration of the sequence identity of at least four base pair units (tandem mismatch and flanking w/c base pairs). These observations underscore the need for rigorous evaluation of thermodynamic parameters describing tandem mismatch stability.

Multiplex SNP discrimination.

Multiplex hybridization reactions of perfectly matched duplexes and duplexes containing a single basepair mismatch (SNPs) were investigated on DNA microarrays. Effects of duplex length, G-C percentage, and relative position of the SNP on duplex hybridization and SNP resolution were determined. Our theoretical model of multiplex hybridization accurately predicts observed results and implicates target concentration as a critical variable in multiplex SNP detection.

Studies of DNA dumbbells VIII. Melting analysis of DNA dumbbells with dinucleotide repeat stem sequences.

Melting curves and circular dichroism spectra were measured for a number of DNA dumbbell and linear molecules containing dinucleotide repeat sequences of different lengths. To study effects of different sequences on the melting and spectroscopic properties, six DNA dumbbells whose stems contain the central sequences (AA)(10), (AC)(10), (AG)(10), (AT)(10), (GC)(10), and (GG)(10) were prepared. These represent the minimal set of 10 possible dinucleotide repeats. To study effects of dinucleotide repeat length, dumbbells with the central sequences (AG)(n), n = 5 and 20, were prepared. Control molecules, dumbbells with a random central sequence, (RN)(n), n = 5, 10, and 20, were also prepared. The central sequence of each dumbbell was flanked on both sides by the same 12 base pairs and T(4) end-loops. Melting curves were measured by optical absorbance and differential scanning calorimetry in solvents containing 25, 55, 85, and 115 mM Na(+). CD spectra were collected from 20 to 45 degrees C and [Na(+)] from 25 to 115 mM. The spectral database did not reveal any apparent temperature dependence in the pretransition region. Analysis of the melting thermodynamics evaluated as a function of Na(+) provided a means for quantitatively estimating the counterion release with melting for the different sequences. Results show a very definite sequence dependence, indicating the salt-dependent properties of duplex DNA are also sequence dependent. Linear DNA molecules containing the (AG)(n) and (RN)(n), sequences, n = 5, 10, 20, and 30, were also prepared and studied. The linear DNA molecules had the exact sequences of the dumbbell stems. That is, the central repeat sequence in each linear duplex was flanked on both sides by the same 12-bp sequence. Melting and CD studies were also performed on the linear DNA molecules. Comparison of results obtained for the same sequences in dumbbell and linear molecular environments reveals several interesting features of the interplay between sequence-dependent structural variability, sequence length, and the unconstrained (linear) or constrained (dumbbell) molecular environments.

Enthalpy/entropy compensation: influence of DNA flanking sequence on the binding of 7-amino actinomycin D to its primary binding site in short DNA duplexes.

The effect of the context of the flanking sequence on ligand binding to DNA oligonucleotides that contain consensus binding sites was investigated for the binding of the intercalator 7-amino actinomycin D. Seven self-complementary DNA oligomers each containing a centrally located primary binding site, 5'-A-G-C-T-3', flanked on either side by the sequences (AT)(n) or (AA)(n) (with n = 2, 3, 4) and AA(AT)(2), were studied. For different flanking sequences, (AA)(n)-series or (AT)(n)-series, differential fluorescence enhancements of the ligand due to binding were observed. Thermodynamic studies indicated that the flanking sequences not only affected DNA stability and secondary structure but also modulated ligand binding to the primary binding site. The magnitude of the ligand binding affinity to the primary site was inversely related to the sequence dependent stability. The enthalpy of ligand binding was directly measured by isothermal titration calorimetry, and this made it possible to parse the binding free energy into its energetic and entropic terms. Our results reveal a pronounced enthalpy-entropy compensation for 7-amino actinomycin D binding to this family of oligonucleotides and suggest that the DNA sequences flanking the primary binding site can strongly influence ligand recognition of specific sites on target DNA molecules.

The four-state model of a linear lattice: application to ligand-controlled hybridization of short duplex DNAs.

An algorithm for calculating the order-disorder transition of a four-state linear lattice is presented. Recursion schemes for the probabilities of each site along the lattice occupying one of the four possible states were derived following the work of D. Poland (Biopolymers, 1974, Vol. 13, pp. 1859-1871) and H. Tachibana and A. Wada (Biopolymers, 1982, Vol. 21, pp. 1873-1885). The algorithm was parameterized to consider melting of short duplex DNA in the presence of duplex and single-strand binding ligands. Model calculations were performed for two 31 base-pair duplex DNAs with very different percent guanine-cytosine base pairs, and thus very different thermodynamic stabilities. In the absence of ligands, calculated melting curves of the two DNAs under identical solvent conditions and identical concentrations were separated by over 15 degrees C. In the presence of either duplex or single-strand binding ligands, if a sequence dependence to ligand binding is assumed, the melting curves of the two DNAs can be made to coalesce, i.e., stability of the two DNAs can be normalized! This example demonstrates the feasibility of controlling hybridization of short DNAs by sequence specific ligand binding.

DNA sequence context and multiplex hybridization reactions: melting studies of heteromorphic duplex DNA complexes.

Heteromorphic hybrid duplex DNA complexes are duplex states, other than perfectly matched duplexes, that can form when single strands comprising several different perfectly matched duplexes are simultaneously present in solution. Such cross-hybridization "side reactions" are of particular nuisance in multiplex reaction schemes, where many strands are designed to hybridize in parallel fashion with only their corresponding perfect complement strand. Relative to the perfect match duplexes, the sequence dependent features of these heteromorphic duplex states and their thermodynamic stability are an important consideration for multiplex hybridization reaction design. We have measured absorbance versus temperature melting curves and performed differential scanning calorimetry measurements on various mixtures of eight different 24 base single strands. When perfect complementary pairs of strands are mixed in single reactions, four perfectly matched duplexes form. When mixtures of strands that are not perfectly matched are prepared and analyzed, melting transitions for cross-hybridization are observed along with significant hyperchromicity changes. This is indicative of a melting hybrid, heteromorphic duplex states formed from two nonperfectly matched strands. In addition, when both the perfectly matched and noncomplementary strands are mixed together (in multiplex hybridization reactions) at molar ratios of 1:1, 3:1, and 1:3, evidence of perfect duplex and heteromorphic duplex complexes is found in all cases. A new analytical tool for considering heterogeneous, duplex complexes in multiplex hybridization mixtures is presented and employed to interpret the acquired melting data.